Butternut Lake
Butternut Lake spans 1,246 acres with an average depth of 25 feet and approximately 18 feet of water clarity, giving it a clean, open-water feel. Located about a half hour east of Eagle River, it sits in a quieter corridor with long stretches of undeveloped shoreline.
With roughly 10 owners per mile of shoreline and significant state-owned frontage, the lake offers notable elbow room and extended forest views. Access includes scenic forest roads that add a bit of travel time but reinforce its tucked-away character.
Butternut appeals to buyers who value depth, clarity, and lower density over proximity, making it a strong fit for swimming, paddling, fishing, and relaxed cruising in a more secluded setting.
Butternut Lake Specs:
Homes for Sale:
Lots for Sale:
150 feet of level sandy frontage on the very desirable Butternut lake. Lot is Perfect for a walk-out basement. Views face East. Butternut Lake is a 1246 acre lake located in Forest County. It has a maximum depth of 42 feet. Fish include Panfish, Smallmouth Bass…
This is a summary based on available information.
Clear, deeper lakes like Butternut tend to produce solid panfish and bass fisheries, with pike and occasional walleye or trout depending on stocking history and habitat. Fish often key on breaks, offshore structure, and edges of weedlines rather than hugging the bank, especially during bright, calm summer conditions. Many anglers fish early and late or on breezy days, using live bait rigs, finesse plastics, and crankbaits to target transition lines where clear water drops into deeper basins. For owners, Butternut often becomes a “quality over quantity” water, where the reward is a mix of good‑eating panfish and the occasional larger bass or pike in a beautiful, low‑pressure setting.
How big is Butternut Lake?
Butternut Lake is 1246 acres with 7.80 miles of shoreline.
How deep is Butternut Lake?
Butternut Lake has an average depth of 25 feet and a maximum depth of 42 feet.
Does Butternut Lake have a boat launch?
Yes, Butternut Lake has a public boat launch.
How far is Butternut Lake from Eagle River?
Butternut Lake is 33 minutes from Eagle River, Wisconsin.
What is the water clarity of Butternut Lake?
Butternut Lake has a water clarity of 18.0 feet.
How long is the shoreline on Butternut Lake?
The shoreline of Butternut Lake is about 7.80 miles.
What type of lake is Butternut Lake?
Butternut Lake is a Spring lake.
What is the trophic status of Butternut Lake?
Butternut Lake is a Oligotrophic lake.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
